Monday, March 16

Tempt My Tummy Tuesday- Nutter Butter Pie


(this was originally posted by me in Aug. 2008)

Welcome back
. If you are new, this is the
Tempt My Tummy Tuesday blog carnival. My twin sister, Lisa, and I co-host the fun. Please post a recipe, kitchen tip, fun food idea, or anything foodie related.

Today, we have Pie, Pie, Me- O-My! It is one of my all time favorites, Nutter Butter Frozen Peanut Butter Pie. Now... That is a NAME! It leaves absolutely nothing to the imagination, but let me tell you it is utter heaven. I know you will love this.


Here is the recipe:

24 Nutter Butter cookies (try with all you might not to eat them... seriously)
1 Pkg. cream cheese, softened
3/4 cup sugar
1 tub of Cool Whip
5 Tbsp butter, melted
1 cup Creamy Peanut Butter
1 Tbsp vanilla

CRUSH cookies and mix with butter. Then press in to the bottom of a pie plate

MIX the cream cheese, peanut butter, sugar and vanilla with an electric mixer on medium speed. Gently stir in 1 1/2 cups of Cool Whip.

FREEZE 4 hours or overnight. Garnish with remaining Cool Whip and cookies.

How EASY is that? I KNOW! Get with it ladies, anyone can do this.

Now, when you make this try to save a little for someone else will ya?

Now... quick... Go see Lisa at Blessed With Grace for Mr. Linky and all the other TMTT fun!



23 comments:

Lisa@BlessedwithGrace said...

Oh my yummy goodness. Me oh my. One of my two most favorite ingredients... PEANUT BUTTER! You ROCK, sister girl!

Gadget Girl said...

Oh stars above... I just gained 5 lbs reading the recipe. I'm going to have to make this, like NOW!!

Deanna said...

Ahhhhhh! (That is me singing!) Yummy! I do a peanut butter pie like your filling but never like your crust. Perfection!!

Lady Why said...

That sounds heavenly!

Lisa@BlessedwithGrace said...

Uh, just so you know, Chris saw the picture of your pie. Oh me oh my... he wants one NOW. You know he is not a big sweet person, but HELLO... he wants THAT!!

Cammie said...

YUM-O! I will be trying this one!

Lynn said...

My husband loves peanut butter. I am going to have to try this.

Channah said...

Ooh, that sounds amazing!

Erica said...

Yummy. I can't wait to have a reason to make this! Well, I might just have to think of a reason because it looks really great!
Thanks for sharing!

Tara @ Feels like home said...

Peanut butter desserts are my biggest food weakness. I just adore them. I'm definitely going to be trying this out at our next family get together. (You know, so that I don't get tempted to eat the whole thing by myself!)

foxxy said...

I love Nutter Butters. They were my favorite cookie as a child. I'll have to try this recipe. Thanks for sharing.

Sarah said...

I just love nutter butters...so this is calling my name :)

Sherry said...

WOW! I love peanut butter!! This sounds absolutely scrumptious!

Brenda said...

I have not had nutter butters forever! This looks great!

Cam said...

I've never seen that pie before and love it :) Thanks for sharing!

Jerri - Simply Sweet Home said...

I make this same recipe. Only it has Hershey Bar shavings mixed in. I love how you used the cookies! My dad makes peanut butter pie too, and he loves nutter butters. I'll have to pass this tip onto him.

JudyBug said...

Oh this has to be delicious! I was looking for a new dessert to take to a church dinner. I believe I have found it!

JudyBug

Angela said...

This looks awesome! I can't wait to try it! Can't promise to save any for others though. I might keep it all for myself, LOL!

Gretchen said...

The pie sounds delicious and thanks for your comment on my blog. It made me laugh! I love your testimony. It is so sweet and wonderful how God works in our lives even when we just don't see hope, He gives us hope. Thank you for sharing it.

Tamara said...

Lana,

It is so nice to meet you! I'm here via your sister's blog (via UBP). I'm a TX girl too (San Antonio). I enjoyed reading your testimony and poking about your blog. I'll be back and will subscribe to your feed!

Kristen said...

Yum, yum, yum - once again yum! This sounds fabulous!

Dazy said...

These butter pies are fab and so tempting, I just can't afford to miss. This would surely keep me busy in the kitchen. My kids just hug me for this.

Omah's Helping Hands said...

I have so been wanting to try this. It is a bit different from another recipe I had found of this. Am definitely going to try this one. The kids will love it! Thanks for sharing.

Google